Moderated Hit list

EuroBillTracker · Post by **EuroBillTracker** » Wed May 22, 2002 1:18 pm

Mr Euro wrote: Okay, now we have only 44 hits. Eeumm, I think we need to rethink the moderating thing again...

What's wrong ? Obviously someone has moderated bills with a small time interval...
PS: I have a log

bhoeyb · Post by **bhoeyb** » Wed May 22, 2002 1:48 pm

EuroBillTracker wrote:
Mr Euro wrote: Okay, now we have only 44 hits. Eeumm, I think we need to rethink the moderating thing again...
What's wrong ? Obviously someone has moderated bills with a small time interval...
PS: I have a log

This is OK, now we have (almost) a realistic hit list

Olivier · Post by **Olivier** » Wed May 22, 2002 2:05 pm

bhoeyb wrote:
EuroBillTracker wrote:
Mr Euro wrote: Okay, now we have only 44 hits. Eeumm, I think we need to rethink the moderating thing again...
What's wrong ? Obviously someone has moderated bills with a small time interval...
PS: I have a log
This is OK, now we have (almost) a realistic hit list

Yes! There is no more serials of same hits, no more hits with less than 24 hours between two registrations... I still have some doubts on some, but it's more realistic than last week!

I have not got any hit yet.

Olivier

TC · Post by TC » Wed May 22, 2002 5:53 pm

and me i haven't any hit too... and i have 2525 bills entered...

Mr Euro · Post by **Mr Euro** » Wed May 22, 2002 9:10 pm

Ok, for me!

smh · Post by **smh** » Wed May 22, 2002 9:15 pm

I was lucky enought to get a hit

About two moderators voting a bill out of the list:
Okay, the month isn't over yet but i was thinking of the following, if someone marks the bill to be removed from the list it couls show up in a second list (only for moderators) and still remain in the main list. Once another moderator marks a bill in that list (or more, whatever you like the best) then the bill should be removed from the main list (and maybe still show up on the moderators list so it can be reactivated again if we found out the hit was real or if the majority decides that it has to come back)

Just my to €0,02

Sander

EuroBillTracker · Post by **EuroBillTracker** » Thu May 23, 2002 10:28 am

smh wrote: About two moderators voting a bill out of the list:
Okay, the month isn't over yet but i was thinking of the following, if someone marks the bill to be removed from the list it couls show up in a second list (only for moderators) and still remain in the main list. Once

Good idea but I think it wouldn't work because it would take every moderator an extra step to check that other list... what a pain. Doing it all in one list wouldn't be more of a problem. It's just that it would force me to add votes... (not that I can't do that... but... humm... let me think... actually, I think I know of an easy way to do that now

But I am still happy with the way the list is right now so I don't want to change anything.

little secret : add &moderate=false to the URL of the list and see what we've escaped now

Olivier · Post by **Olivier** » Thu May 23, 2002 2:04 pm

EuroBillTracker wrote: little secret : add &moderate=false to the URL of the list and see what we've escaped now

7 hits for a bill in just a few days...

O.

Finn · Post by **Finn** » Fri May 24, 2002 11:17 am

First I have say I haven't been on the board much recently so I don't what has been discussed in other threads.

I'm not sure if moderation rules are clear to me, how about others? I had two hits on the list but now they're gone. It is true they were not necessarily real hits as notes didn't travel from hand to hand that much (they were new, uncirculated non-Finnish notes), but in my opinion they were real hits because a) they were not done to get hits b) it happened between two persons who don't know each other at all. I do understand it is very difficult for moderators to know what is real and what is not, my hits could be fake, but if that was the case they sure would have be done better

So, what is the criteria for a real hit? Geographical distance, time difference, how the moderators feel right then? What if I withdraw money from ATM next to a store, write down both codes, walk in the store and pay by cash. Then next person in cashier line gets my note and both of us go where we can use internet and of course enter our notes. There may be not big time difference and no geographical distance at all but still hit was honest in my opinion (but not necessarily that interesting..).

I know this is next to impossible thing to handle and keep everyone happy as long as there are hit-hungry people.

EuroBillTracker · Post by **EuroBillTracker** » Fri May 24, 2002 1:14 pm

Finn wrote: I'm not sure if moderation rules are clear to me, how about others? I had (...)hits could be fake, but if that was the case they sure would have be done better

Send me the bill serial by email and I will unmoderate them !

Finn wrote: So, what is the criteria for a real hit? Geographical distance, time difference, how the moderators feel right then? What if I withdraw money

Basically yeah... and since this is a human endeavor it is bound to have faults

Anyway, I think I'll send a mail to them to consider bills up to today to be ok and not to play around with them.

Finn wrote: I know this is next to impossible thing to handle and keep everyone happy as long as there are hit-hungry people.

Yeah... try that moderate=false thing and you'll see what's going on behind the scenes !

PS: Thanks for being cool about your bills ! Oh... and it helps if people write a comment about where they got a bill. Obviously it won't be moderated if it says "got it from such and such atm..."

Olivier · Post by **Olivier** » Fri May 24, 2002 2:39 pm

EuroBillTracker wrote:
Finn wrote: So, what is the criteria for a real hit? Geographical distance, time difference, how the moderators feel right then? What if I withdraw money
Basically yeah... and since this is a human endeavor it is bound to have faults
Anyway, I think I'll send a mail to them to consider bills up to today to be ok and not to play around with them.

I think the criteria which shows a hit is false are:
- several bills are registered by the same couple of players. For instance the couple JYCCE/Mikaz (Finland) which had registered two bills in two days. It can't be by chance.
- a bill has been registered twice in less than 24h. It may be the same person with two accounts... or two friends.

EuroBillTracker wrote: it helps if people write a comment about where they got a bill. Obviously it won't be moderated if it says "got it from such and such atm..."

I agree!
It's also funny to know how a bill has been got, when you mark a hit or not.

Olivier

Finn · Post by **Finn** » Wed Jun 05, 2002 8:21 am

Olivier wrote: I think the criteria which shows a hit is false are:
- several bills are registered by the same couple of players. For instance the couple JYCCE/Mikaz (Finland) which had registered two bills in two days. It can't be by chance.

Don't know if list is still actively moderated or not, and I don't want to play a netcop or anything, just noticed that bills U0x395155xxx and P0x863890xxx are from same persons. A used them in the same place, but different days, B magically received both on different days. Can it really happen I wonder

EuroBillTracker · Post by **EuroBillTracker** » Wed Jun 05, 2002 11:13 am

Finn wrote: Don't know if list is still actively moderated or not, and I don't want to play a netcop or anything, just noticed that bills U0x395155xxx and P0x863890xxx are from same persons. A used them in the same place, but different days, B magically received both on different days. Can it really happen I wonder

That's de-jo... he told me it was a real hit. Care to say more de-jo ?