emmem wrote:
nti Täti wrote:
... memes are cultural genes, they're aiming to be cloned to as many minds as possible, ...
My opinion about this is that not all the memes are urging their host to duplicate them. For instance a secret can be considered as a meme too. A secret is an information patern, it is held within an individual's memory. And it is capable of being copied to another individual's memory. But the secret will only be copied by effective interrogation or by torturing the keeper of the secret.
I see secrets this way: "a secret" is actually a block of many memes, and the secretmeme is a value that dominates the others. The thing we keep as a secret can't be duplicated, because the secretmeme is so powerful, it's really deep inside us that if something is a secret it must be kept. Of course sometimes the sectermeme is broken by the gossipmeme, if the individual is conviced that gossiping brings more happiness than keeping a secret, if the mind is more open to the gossipmeme to dominate.
Secretmeme is actually a really groundmeme, it is spread all over, because secrets are way to keep our faces and we learn quite early that if we keep somethig to ourselves, it is called as a secret. And if the secret is something that we have heard from someone else and have been told to keep it as a secret, we have gotten some information and an activation of a meme.
Oh, it surely has been too long since my latest english lesson, I can't type my thoughts here clear enough. But at least I tried to get my point to you.
I think that the memetheory casts nearly everything, if you just put some effort on finding the memes behind actions and thoughts you find it, but all the same I'm not sure is it always worth searching: sometimes it is easier to border some thoughts like information out of the term of memes, usually I think values and other thoughts that make us act some particular way as memes and leave things like news about something that someone has done out of the word.
Argh. I'm really confusing today.
Oh, yes. That against the population-thing. Like I wrote (or did I leave it out of the ready message? Can't remember), memes aren't good or bad, they just are. They don't exist for bringing good for the population, for example those "that particular moment we all must kill ourselves"-cults are possible because of memes, the leader of the cult spreads a strong meme and those people who are in the cult don't question any actions the leader says they should do, because they have a meme about the leader being right in their minds.
Nature isn't sane creature and people aren't nothing but chimp species, so memes don't have to be logic and they don't get into someone's mind because they are good for us, it is enought that they are powerful enough to be spread. Like genes, memes aren't always perfect, they can mutate too orsomethinglikethat. I mean, that memes are like genes, and there are genes that aren't good for the population, for example some genes that cause several problems in the body like genes that are the cause of handicapped being built other way than the others etc.
Kohtuus kaikessa mutta liioitella saa aina.